Press Release

Green Steel Label: CMA and bvse warn against greenwashing

Production process of billets at NLMK Kaluga, the next-generation EAF mill (NLMK Group)

CMA and bvse are calling for a European green steel label that makes the actual CO₂ footprint of steel visible. Verifiable emissions should be the decisive factor, regardless of the production process.

Berlin/Bonn/Düsseldorf, 19 June 2026 – The associations CMA Circular Metal Association (formerly BDSV & VDM) and bvse are advocating to the EU Commission for a credible European green steel label that makes actual climate benefits visible, strengthens the circular economy, and offers reliable guidance for customers, investors, and public procurement. At the same time, the two associations urgently warn against the introduction of a so-called sliding scale as the basis for defining green steel.

According to the associations, a green steel label must follow a simple principle: green steel must be steel with low, comprehensible, and verifiable emissions. The actual Product Carbon Footprint should be the decisive factor – not the question of which production route a steel product comes from or how difficult the transformation of individual plants is.

The sliding scale fails to meet this requirement. It adjusts emission limits based on the proportion of steel scrap used. The higher the recycling content, the stricter the limit. Conversely, production routes with lower use of recycled raw materials are given more generous thresholds. This means that steel with higher actual emissions can receive a favourable ‘green’ classification, while recycling-based production methods, which are already significantly lower in emissions, are subject to stricter requirements.

“A green steel label must not lead to higher emissions being methodologically sugar-coated. Anyone who wants to define green steel must measure actual environmental performance – not protect historical production structures,” CMA and bvse jointly declare.
The associations see the sliding scale as a structural disadvantage for circular production methods. The use of recycled steel is one of the most mature, scalable, and effective ways to reduce emissions in steel production. It reduces the need for primary raw materials, energy, and emission-intensive ore and coal-based production. From the associations’ perspective, a methodology that mathematically weakens this advantage or translates it into stricter requirements sends the wrong signal to the market and policymakers.

CMA and bvse are particularly critical of the potential consequences for lead markets and public procurement. If products with significantly different actual CO₂ footprints are classified into comparable performance categories, the label loses its guiding function. Public funds could then flow into products that only appear ‘green’ due to methodological adjustments. This would not contribute to effective climate policy but would pose a significant greenwashing risk.

Instead, the associations support the approach of further developing the methodology within the framework of the European Ecodesign Regulation for Sustainable Products. The basis developed by the European Commission’s Joint Research Centre correctly focuses on the Product Carbon Footprint and comparable environmental performance classes. This approach should be maintained but made more ambitious so that the label drives actual decarbonisation and does not merely certify the status quo.

From the associations’ perspective, the availability of steel scrap must not serve as a justification for weakening the label. While recycled steel is circular, material availability is not unlimited. However, it does not follow that its environmental benefits should be downgraded in the label. The correct response lies in better collection, sorting, and processing structures, demanding quality standards, recycling-friendly product design, and stable markets for secondary raw materials.

At the same time, CMA and bvse warn against linking the debate on green steel with demands for export restrictions on recycled steel. Recycled steel is an internationally needed raw material for lower-emission steel production. Trade restrictions would not automatically lead to greater use in Europe but could distort markets, weaken collection incentives, and make investments in quality and processing more difficult.

CMA and bvse therefore call on European decision-makers to exclude sliding-scale-based approaches from the green steel definition, public procurement, lead markets, and funding instruments. A credible label must be based on actual, verifiable emissions, recognise recycled raw materials as a central decarbonisation lever, and closely involve the recycling industry in further methodology development.

Conclusion of the associations: The sliding scale should not be improved, weakened, or relabelled. It should be rejected.

The detailed position paper can be found in German here.

Press Contact

Portrait of Bernd Meyer

Bernd Meyer

International Association & Industry Engagement

Share article

Further press releases

CMA INDEX*
STEEL SCRAP PRICES IN GERMANY IN €/t (10/2026)**

Grade 1

253.6 €/t

Grade 2

293.7 €/t

Grade 3

287.5 €/t

Grade 4

301.1 €/t

Grade 5

246.6 €/t

*Previously BDSV Average Prices
**Reports from member companies of the BDSV (Federal Association of German Steel Recycling and Waste Management Companies) on prices and quantities to a neutral reporting agency (IW Consult). IW Consult acts exclusively on behalf of the BDSV, is solely responsible for technical implementation, and assumes no liability or warranty. The reporting period runs from the 1st to the 20th of the current month. The prices to be reported are exclusively ex-station prices (warehouse sales prices – loaded free on wagon, free on lorry or free on ship from site). Prices for new scrap grades 2 and 8 are recorded together.

For non-members, the BDSV average prices are published from the 10th day of the following month. Find out about your benefits of membership here.

Please refer to the Steel Scrap Grade List for the specifications of the individual steel scrap grades.

Switch to German