Press Release

CMA survey: Shortage of DB Cargo wagons burdens recycling companies

A CMA survey of 79 member companies reveals significant problems with the provision of empty wagons by DB Cargo. Consequently, 82.2 per cent were unable to fulfil their supply contracts, or could only do so partially.

Berlin, Düsseldorf, Brussels, 15/09/2026 – Rail logistics for recycled metals in Germany is no longer a reliable system. This is the finding of a snap survey conducted by the Circular Metal Association (CMA) on the provision of empty wagons by DB Cargo, in which a total of 79 member companies participated fully between 3 and 27 August 2026. The questions covered the period from January to June 2026. The ratings are consistently in the critical range – and they continue to deteriorate.

Recycled metals are a central raw material for European industry – recycled steel primarily supplies the electric steel route, while recycled non-ferrous metals go to remelting plants and foundries. These volumes cannot be moved spontaneously. They require wagons, timetables, and commitments that can be relied upon. This is exactly what is lacking.

No grade better than 3.7

Ratings were based on a school grade scale from 1 (very good) to 6 (fail). No sub-aspect of the provision of empty wagons achieved a grade better than 3.7:

– Provision of empty wagons overall: 4.0
– Provision of promised or confirmed volumes: 3.9
– Information regarding missing, delayed, or incomplete empty wagons: 3.8
– Punctuality: 3.7

The development during the current year is particularly clear: 51.9 per cent of companies report a deterioration since the beginning of 2026. The vast majority of these – 41.8 per cent of all respondents – describe the deterioration as significant.
Only 10.1 per cent see an improvement.

“We are not talking about a few bad weeks here,” says Andreas Schwenter, Vice President of the CMA. “Companies have been reporting the same pattern for years: promised wagons arrive too late, incomplete, or not at all. The only thing that is new is that the situation is measurably deteriorating further – despite all the discussions we have held with DB Cargo.”

Six out of ten companies receive significantly fewer wagons than ordered

The supply gap is substantial. 34.2 per cent of companies state that, on average, more than 30 per cent of the ordered wagons failed to arrive. A further 26.6 per cent report a shortfall of between 11 and 30 per cent. Together, this represents more than 60 per cent of respondents whose scheduling, on average, faced a gap in the first half of the year. Only 3.8 per cent report almost complete delivery.

The consequences directly impact day-to-day business: 82.2 per cent of companies were unable to fulfil supply contracts, or could only do so partially, due to insufficient or unpunctual wagon provision. The most frequently cited consequences include substitute transport by lorry (71.4 per cent), additional scheduling and personnel effort (67.5 per cent), delayed deliveries and contracts not fully fulfilled (64.9 per cent each), and strained customer relationships (58.4 per cent).

Losses in the millions due to unreliable rail freight transport

The unreliability also has financial repercussions. 72.2 per cent of companies report financial disadvantages or at least partial disadvantages, while a further 17.7 per cent cannot yet quantify the damage. Only 10.1 per cent deny any financial losses. Where figures are available, they reach damage categories of over €500,000.
“If the wagons fail to arrive, a recycling company cannot fulfil its contracts – and loses not only margin but also customers,” says Schwenter. “In the end, the costs of this unreliability are borne by our industry alone, not by DB Cargo.”

Too few wagons, too little personnel

The companies identify the biggest problem areas as too few empty wagons (68.4 per cent), personnel shortages at the railway and service providers (62.0 per cent), and delayed provision of empty wagons (49.4 per cent). These are followed by excessively high freight rates (48.1 per cent), as well as unfulfilled volume commitments and missing or late information at 43.0 per cent each.

From the CMA’s perspective, this presents a clear picture. The rail logistics of recycling companies are not suffering from isolated disruptions, but from a structural performance and capacity crisis. For companies, this means rising costs, contractual risks, and less predictability. Added to this is a contradiction in transport policy. The Federal Government wants to increase rail’s market share of freight transport to at least 25 per cent by 2030, yet the practice of empty wagon provision is driving cargo in the other direction – onto the road. 71.4 per cent of respondents cite substitute transport by lorry as one of the most significant consequences.

“Every lorry that our members commission as a substitute is cargo shifting from rail to road. Some of it will not return, because no dispatcher relies twice on a mode of transport that lets them down,” says Schwenter. “Anyone who wants to shift freight transport to rail must first make rail reliable. At the moment, our industry is learning the opposite every week.”

What the CMA demands

The CMA demands binding volume commitments from DB Cargo, resilient capacity and personnel planning, sufficient suitable rolling stock, and early and honest information when empty wagons are not provided or only partially provided. From politicians, the association expects that the reliability of single-wagon transport becomes a measurable condition for state funding and that the interests of the raw materials and recycling industry are taken into account in the rail freight transport strategy.

“We do not expect miracles, but predictability: binding volumes, reliable deadlines, and open communication when something doesn’t work out,” says Schwenter. “As long as this is missing, any debate about shifting transport remains a rhetorical exercise – and the supply of recycled raw materials to the steel industry remains a daily improvisation project.”
About the Circular Metal Association (CMA)

__________________________

About the Circular Metal Association (CMA)

The Circular Metal Association is Europe’s leading industry association for steel and metal recycling. Approximately 900 member companies cover the entire spectrum: from collection and processing to trade and the supply of the metal and steel processing industry. Around 90 per cent of the industry companies active in the market are organised within the CMA. Its members supply the recycled raw materials that European industry works with – making them an indispensable part of the European raw materials industry. The CMA was formed from the merger of the Federal Association of German Steel Recycling and Waste Management Companies (BDSV) and the Association of German Metal Traders (VDM).

We create certainty.

Press Contact

Portrait of Bernd Meyer

Bernd Meyer

International Association & Industry Engagement

Share article

Further press releases

CMA INDEX*
STEEL SCRAP PRICES IN GERMANY IN €/t (10/2026)**

Grade 1

253.6 €/t

Grade 2

293.7 €/t

Grade 3

287.5 €/t

Grade 4

301.1 €/t

Grade 5

246.6 €/t

*Previously BDSV Average Prices
**Reports from member companies of the BDSV (Federal Association of German Steel Recycling and Waste Management Companies) on prices and quantities to a neutral reporting agency (IW Consult). IW Consult acts exclusively on behalf of the BDSV, is solely responsible for technical implementation, and assumes no liability or warranty. The reporting period runs from the 1st to the 20th of the current month. The prices to be reported are exclusively ex-station prices (warehouse sales prices – loaded free on wagon, free on lorry or free on ship from site). Prices for new scrap grades 2 and 8 are recorded together.

For non-members, the BDSV average prices are published from the 10th day of the following month. Find out about your benefits of membership here.

Please refer to the Steel Scrap Grade List for the specifications of the individual steel scrap grades.

Switch to German